Friday, September 2, 2016
Why Teaching?
ENGAGE: Ch. 1 Focus Questions (Week 1)
I think we can combine the first of the two set of questions because they have some overlap.
1. What are the advantages and disadvantages of being a teacher?
2. What are the satisfactions—and complaints—of today's teachers?
We all have an ideal of what the teaching profession ought to be. We also know that ideal just doesn't exist. But there are elements to that ideal that make us want to be in the profession: It's a rewarding profession, where you can be intellectually stimulated, where you can help young people grow, and where you can teach a subject you're passionate about and inspire others to be interested in.
But it's also a frustrating profession. American culture seems to have inoculated students from finding any enjoyment in education. We have a deeply apathetic culture which places a very low value on education. This is why there are such strong problems with the educational system today. A strong strand of anti-intellectualism persists. Young people are raised in a culture of celebrity that prizes fame and wealth above all other pursuits.
The structure in place is also another headache. The bureaucratic structure places demands on teachers. It insists that teachers teach certain things in a certain ways. This can sap away creativity and Independence. The current system is also fixated on teaching to the test. High test score have become more highly valued than critical thinking skills.
Dissatisfaction can set in on top of all this due to low wages, heavy work loads, and a general lack of support.
3. Can we consider teaching to be a profession?
I think that it's a problem that this is a question we need to answer at all in the first place. It is a profession. There's no ifs, ands, or buts about it. To me, it's deeply unsettling that people want to split hairs as to why it does or does not qualify as a profession.
The general argument made against teaching as a profession is that unlike doctors or lawyers, teachers don't have a specific universal body of knowledge that they have to acquire in order to enter the job.
The fact is that most people think anyone can be a teacher. This gives them the license to judge teachers and criticize educational policy and question what is being taught in schools. But the reality is that teachers are the only people with the proper background necessary to be making any real judgement calls about schools.
4. How has teacher preparation changed over the years?
Well, in truth, not very much has changed. A significant amount of teacher candidates are still taught in colleges (like they were back in the 19th century) where they learn how to become teachers. Educational reformers have argued that this isn't enough. They would like to see sense of professionalism and stronger, more national certifications.
Additionally, in more recent years, a number of alternative certifications programs, most notably Teach for America, have allowed people to become teachers through on hands experience. While this has given pause to many educators about the future of teachers being acknowledged as professionals, everything I've heard about Teach for America has been mixed. Some have had invaluable experiences and appreciate the on-hands opportunities, but many have found themselves wildly out of their depth in America's most at risk and high need schools.
5. What are the differences between the National Education Association and the American Federation of Teachers?
Both the National Educational Association (NEA) and American Federation of Teachers (AFT) are professional organizations for teachers. They both help unions and advocate on behalf of teachers. They both provide resources and professional development to teachers. However, the NEA is older and larger, and the AFT is smaller, more urban, and is associated with the labor movement.
6. What traits and characteristics are needed for successful teaching?
Well, for starters, a teacher needs to love children. They also need to love learning and love what they teach. In fact, love is going to get thrown around a lot in this answer because good teachers require a love for a very precise combination of things. Other things they need to love, or at least like: working in and building communities and working with people; it is, after all, a people person profession. Good teachers also tend to be curious, passionate, and highly self-motivated.
7. Is teaching a "good fit" for you?
I'm a bit of introverted person. This sometimes fails to make it readily apparent that I might be good in front of a classroom. However, once I begin talking about the things that interest me and that I'm passionate about, I get in the zone.
I went into teaching out of a longstanding desire to work with young people. I was a camp counselor for a number of years and seeing young people grow up, develop and come into their own was one of the most satisfying experiences I've ever had. There aren't many professions that offer that sort of opportunity.
I also just love my content area; I'm a geek when it comes to history. It's honestly just best if you don't get me started talking about it because you might be there awhile.
Additionally, I had many very good teachers. I had teachers who were so knowledgeable that it was a tiny bit frightening and you couldn't help but admire them. I had passionate and engaged teachers. Most importantly, I had teachers who made it their mission to see their students grow. The best teachers I had cultivated you as a human being and a citizen. They wanted to make you a better person.
To me, if I could do the same for others as was done for me, I don't think anything would please me quite as much as that.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment