Sunday, October 23, 2016

Stranger Things

ELABORATE: What Do you Think?

What school and community resources might you use to help immigrant students?

I would encourage immigrant students to seek English as a New Language services if that is necessary for them and they are a first generation immigrant.  I would also suggest that they get involved with community outreach programs the school may have.  This will help to get people to stop viewing immigrant students as Others who should be feared. To bridge the cultural barrier and to build acceptance, immigrant students might form clubs (like the "Russian Club" shown in the video) so that people may begin to understand their culture and so that a dialogue will be initiated.

Multiculturalism

EVALUATE

I was quite proud of my ability to successfully pass the Multicultural Literacy Game-Quiz. Admittedly, I did not know all of these. I knew the majority from my knowledge about history and culture. But about 3 (Nisei, Lumpia, Step Show) towards the end I arrived at through process of elimination. 

 

This really is a diverse nation, and we need to be better about acknowledging that diversity. If our instruction is not culturally relevant, we won't get through to our students and they won't learn. So in a sense, it is a tiny bit of a wake up call that I still have certain multicultural blind-spots. I need to work at that.  

Different Ways of Learning

ENGAGE: Different Ways of Learning

1. Schools and classrooms should be quiet places to promote thinking and learning.

B. Agree

There are times when it's perfectly fine for classrooms to be a little more chaotic, filled with energy and the noise of conversation and debate. But these times have to be specific parts of the lessons and curriculum. They cannot be the typical expected baseline state of the school. It is difficult to run a classroom and to maintain student attention when they're not able to focus.   

2. All classrooms and libraries should be well lighted to reduce eyestrain.

A. Strongly Agree

Schools should be well lit so that students are able to get their work done, but also so that they feel safe and secure in their classrooms. Brighter lighting not only reduces eyestrain, but it increases a sense of a positivity.

3. Difficult subjects, such as math, should be offered in the morning, when students are fresh and alert.

C. Disagree

This just feels like a bad question. Students are rarely fresh and alert in the morning. Teachers prefer early classes because students are quiet and subdued as a result of only recently having gotten out of bed.  But I'm not sure if that necessarily means students are more prepared to think during this time of the day. In fact, the opposite may very well be true. The argument against classes later in the day is that students are less focused due to having more energy (especially after lunch) and being all ready to head back home at the end of the school day.

4. School thermostats should be set at 68 to 72 degrees Fahrenheit to establish a comfortable learning environment.

B. Agree

I'm perfectly fine with that temperature; it seems reasonable. But everyone's body reacts differently to the temperature buildings are set to. So it very well could bother some people.

5. Eating and drinking in classrooms should be prohibited.

C. Disagree

Perhaps if you were a science teacher who was concerned about lab materials mixing with the food and drinks students were having, you might be concerned about eating in the classroom. But as a social studies teacher, food and drinks aren't that large of a concern. I'm as worried as anyone else of students making a mess as a result of eating. But some students don't have lunches or need to eat something to keep up their energy. If it helps them maintain focus and contribute to class, I'm not going to oppose it.

6. Classroom periods should run between forty-five and fifty-five minutes to ensure adequate time to investigate significant issues and practice important skills.

B. Agree

I wouldn't want a period shorter than somewhere in the 40 minute ranger; there just wouldn't be enough time to actually do anything. That said, I also wouldn't want a class period running more than 45 minutes quite honestly. Students quickly get jittery towards the end of a class period, and the longer the period drags out, the less likely they will be paying attention. Plenty can get done in 45 minutes, and if you really want to spend a lot of time on something, you can break it up over the course of more than one day.

7. Students must be provided with adequate work areas, including chairs and desks, where they can sit quietly for the major part of their learning and study.

B. Agree

Students need adequate work spaces. But sitting perfectly quiet as they learn isn't necessarily the most effective form of instruction. They'll be times where students need to study and learn quietly at their desk, but I wouldn't expect that to be the case all the time.

8. Emphasis should be placed on reading textbooks and listening to lectures, for this is how students learn best.

C. Disagree

Textbooks are boring. Social studies textbooks are perhaps the most boring academic textbooks of all. They fail to frame history as a narrative, they avoid trying to stir up controversy, they leave out some of the most interesting and fascinating details, they fail to make connections among topics, they fail to provide context, and they don't make connections to current or modern events.  Social studies textbooks are also frequently inaccurate (As demonstrated so beautifully in James W. Loewen's Lies My Teacher Told Me), favoring moral instillment over accurate history.

Lecturing is boring if overused. But, as I've repeatedly said, direct instruction is inevitably the primary form of instruction; so we need find ways to improve it and make it engaging, rather than writing it off as terrible. Textbook readings can be replaced with higher quality alternative readings. The same can be achieved for direct instruction.

Sunday, October 16, 2016

Digital Pedagogy

EXPLORE: What is Digital Pedagogy?

 

Digital pedagogy is simply enhancing traditional pedagogy with digital technology. The article mentions the recent trend of the "flipped classroom", where instruction happens at home through online resources and then students practice skills based on that instruction in the classroom. This seems like it will be particularly effective for math and science classrooms, which might find themselves struggling to create time for reinforcement of problem solving. 

 

The article mocks power points, but I think it's a little too harsh on the second most popular feature of the Microsoft Office Suite. Notes still need to be delivered to students, and the alternative is the old talk and chalk method. The problem isn't the delivery system but rather the delivery. Power Point tends to be boring because teachers who use it tend to be... well, boring. Power Point can be tremendously useful when teacher elaborate on terms and concepts presented on the power point slides and when they have additional information to discuss beyond the power point. Too often teachers simply repeat what's up on the power point. Your students can read it; now give them a reason to care.

I'm a fan of the idea of students essentially journaling using Moodle sites (such as our own e-class) or blogging sites. Social studies requires students to express their opinions about historical events with competing opinions and perspectives, and contested facts and details. Students, in my opinion, should also engage with current events and formulate opinions about pressing topics about things going on in the world. They should also learn to make connections between the history they're learning and events happening in the news. Informal writing could be done with your standard pencil and looseness, but students may find more enjoyment and ease in a familiar technological resource.


Digital pedagogy, in short, is just pedagogy. Pedagogy for a new era, but pedagogy who's fundamentals don't look all that different from the past.

Teachers as Facilitators

EXPLORE and EXPLAIN: PPT Models of Teaching

 

Teachers as facilitators is a trend we're increasingly seeing in education. Instead of teachers simply directly providing all the necessary information and being the key source of knowledge, teachers as facilitators act as guides and generate circumstances and tasks under which students will learn. When the teacher is a facilitator, students discover knowledge on their own and learn more independently and collaboratively. Instruction tries to move away from traditional direct instruction. 

Falling into Place

EXPLORE: Four Models of Instruction

 

I find myself falling between Social Constructvism and Cognitive Constructivism. The former emphasizes the environment in which students learn, while the latter focuses on the individual existing educational foundations of students. I think education is based on a combination of both. It's based on what students bring to the table, but it's also about promoting a learning environment in which students learn. Learning is built into the social and cultural circumstances on instruction. But I think Social Constructvism makes the great point that motivation is based on a combination extrinsic things (grades, teacher expectations) and intrinsic things (interest in a topic). 

Teaching to the Test

ENGAGE: What do you think?

 

If the primary goal of education is to create genuine interest in students of learning, then we're doing a pretty terrible job at it. We bribe, we coerce, we shame. But we rarely find ways to create authentic interest. It's temporary and based around getting a good good grade, or out competing some fellow student, or making sure we pass the test. These are bad ways to create motivation in students. 

 

School reform advocate Alfie Kohn gets at all of this and more. He makes the case that running schools like a business is a problematic system. Standards and grades are all about ensuring accountability, like a company to its shareholders. It becomes less about a real concern about actual learning and more about visibly proving "success" through data points. Aren't happy with teacher performance? Tie it to student test grades. 

 

Education has become obsessed with rote memorization at the expense of critical thinking. We prize worksheets and poorly made power point presentations, endless homework (a series of busybody worksheets that insult students' intelligence) and prescribed tests (that we, of course, teach to). Kohn argues that if schools emphasized a Progressive education more then they would see students capable of making meaningful decisions.  

 

Schools underwhelm gifted learners. They're bored, they fail to be challenged, and they're frustrated with the repetition. Schools stress out struggling learners. They're frustrated, and they typically coast by under the radar,   

 

Students need to be legitimately challenged because it encourages them to think in ways that will make them prepared for the world. They'll be able to challenge and critique authority, and they'll call into question everything. They'll be inquisitive, and they won't accept things at face value. Ultimately, we need to make students who can affect real world change and know how to go about achieving it. The current system just doesn't do that.  

The Future of Education



Looking to the future of education is a reminder that some things will change drastically and others will largely remain the same. 

After reading the article 5 Big Ways Education Will Change By 2020, I was reminded of the extraordinary impact technology has had on society.  But as the article points out, I was also reminded that despite the incredible change technology as wrought, classrooms look very similar to how they’ve always looked.  People still remain skeptical of online class (even one such as the one we’re doing right now), and people still doubt technology really being able to entirely replace certain fundamental aspects of education.  But I think the article is right, more students are going to being attending classes remotely; this will happen as result of digital technology and students having been raised on digital tech, but also because of the cost benefits that distance education offers.

However, we shouldn’t get ahead of ourselves about the role of technology.  Technology may be new and shiny and seem like the cure-all-fix-all solution, but it can’t replace the role of a quality teacher.  Teachers should be determining instruction not technology.  The tail shouldn’t wag the dog.

Higher education is important, but it isn’t for everyone.  Too many students are encouraged to go to college to get degrees they may not have even gotten the first place if they had considered alternative options.  As important as I think history is, a history degree won’t build a house or fix a car.  Trade schools should be taken more seriously than they have been.

As I’ve said repeatedly, student focused education has its place and is not seen often enough in the classroom.  But I also find that it has its limits.  Just like teachers aren’t going away, neither is direct instruction.  Students should have a voice, students’ interests should be taken seriously, and greater space for meeting their needs should be created.  Greater co-operative and inquiry-based instruction should be initiated, and more extracurricular activities should be offered.  But I think, ultimately, the greater problem is disinterested and under-qualified educators.  

I think the final point the article makes is probably its most astute.  The goal of education is ultimately to prepare students for the world.  A changing world requires a changing approach to education.  That will mean that various aspects of all the previous discussed changes will begin to see greater application in the world of education. 

Saturday, October 8, 2016

Where Do You Stand?


ELABORATE: Where do you Stand?

Here is my Emaze presentation about where I stand on the philosophy spectrum.

Do you find yourself influenced more by the arguments supporting teacher-centered approaches, or those advocating student-centered approaches? Are there elements of each that you find appealing? How will your classroom practices reflect your philosophy?

The self-assessment test "Who Are you as an Educator" pegged me as a Social Reconstructionist, but the placement of it on the spectrum for "Where Do You Stand on the Philosophy Spectrum?" makes it seem far too much to the student-centered approach to education. If we go by the spectrum, I'm probably a Progressive. However, I've repeatedly made criticisms of Progressivism in posts on this blog. My biggest critique is that, as I understand it, its approach to education is vague and difficult to pin down. I understand being concerned about students' interests and being creative, but I feel that Progressivism is impractical and doesn't fully grasp the realities of day-to-day education. Progressivism, to me, ignores the important role of an instructor. While teachers can be great big bores who don't build instruction to engage students more thoroughly, that doesn't mean that they don't matter what-so-ever. Direct instruction has gotten a bad name; however, it's invariably the chief form of instruction, and educational philosophies that don't acknowledge this and attempt to find ways to improve it are doing a disservice to teachers. 

Ultimately, however, I keep falling towards student centered approaches whenever I assess myself for it. But as I mentioned in in a previous post, I find something worth borrowing in just about every educational philosophy. There isn't a one size fit all philosophy that could possibly suit all my philosophical beliefs or needs. 

I imagine my classroom practices will feature a variety of approaches to instruction, depending on what I'm teaching, who I'm teaching and how I can make it work for what I believe education should look like. 

Friday, October 7, 2016

Essentialism in Action


EVALUATE
  1. What are the advantages and disadvantages of this competitive approach to learning?
  2. Why are these topics appropriate for an essentialist classroom?
  3. What are the dangers inherent in any essentialist approach?
  4. What changes could have been done to transform this activity into a constructivist one?

1. Adding an element of competition into the classroom can generate excitement and enthusiasm, which can encourage learning. But sometimes students may be blinded by the competition and the score; they may only care about winning and forget the real reason they are playing the game in the first place. We certainly see that in the video. The students get visibly frustrated and upset. The one boy slams is fists on the desk, and the boy and the girl sullenly lay their heads down on the desk when they lose at the end. Additionally, these two students intimidate the rest of their group and prevent them from enjoying the activity.

2. Essentialism is built around a very academically rigorous curriculum based on very concrete topics. The Jeopardy-style activity questions are all knowledge based questions within academically traditional topics, namely spelling and geography. 

3. Essentialist approaches are limited in their view of the purpose of education. They assume that the mere acquisition of knowledge is the key to a successful education. This discourages more conceptual and skills-based forms of education.

4. This lesson could have been turned into a constructivist-style activity by potentially having the students design the questions which were asked to the class. It could have also been made more constructivist by asking additional follow up questions after the Jeopardy questions were asked; this would have led to the probing of students’ interests related to these topics.

Changing the World



EXPLAIN: Complete the Task:

A. In writing, discuss which of the philosophies of education and the learning orientations are closest to you? Why? Which do not fit with your philosophy of education and learning? Why? 

I feel like there are elements of all the educational philosophies that fit my perspective on education. Essentialism may be limiting in its approach, but I agree with the ideas that curriculum should be designed by teachers, mastery of materials should be a key priority, and a certain degree of rigor ought to exist. On the other hand, Perennialism is also very rigid. But I do appreciate its emphasis on reasoning and moral values and its focus on the big picture rather than an endless series of facts. I like Progressivism's hands on take of education, but I often wonder just how practical this approach is to education (i.e. this can't be done every single day). Social Reconstructionism is pretty cool; it insists on education with real world experiences and an understanding of the world in order to create real world change. I can get behind Existentialism's abolition of grades, but I also like its insistence on students coming to better understand themselves. Constructivism places a premium on guiding students until you're certain they've actually learned what you've wanted them to learn. But perhaps it's greatest underlying principle is that students should constantly question pre-existing assumptions. Behaviorism recognizes that you get more out of students by treating them positively than negatively, and rewarding them for doing well. It's scientific in its approach and its gradual in its handling instruction. 
  
B. Discuss how the branches of philosophy (metaphysics, epistemology, and/or axiology) are related to the world view philosophies, philosophies of education, and learning theories. 

The branches of philosophy are just much more overarching categories for viewing the world. Educational philosophies get much more specific but are essentially trying to answer the same sort of questions posed by the philosophical branches: What is real? How do we know what we know? What is of value? How do we reason? What is beautiful? Learning theories try to find more concrete ways of answering these questions: Progressivism insists on exploration, Perennialism tries to find enduring truths as answers. Constructivism hopes by going out into the world people can learn through real world experience, etc. 

C. Take the Educational Philosophies Self-Assessment. Score yourself using the Educational Philosophies Self-Assessment Scoring Guide. 

This was a close run race with three different philosophies receiving 20's (Progressivism, Cognitivism, Humanism), all of which, based on their descriptions, I can certainly understand why they scored so high. But Reconstructionism/Critical Theory eked out a victory with a 24 (one point shy of a perfect score), and based on its description definitely deserved to be the top philosophy. I'm very idealistic in my views of education as a transformative enterprise committed to social change. I believe that begins by getting students to think critically, ask questions and understand things from multiple perspectives.

D. Were there any discrepancies between your original ideas about which educational philosophy fit you (part B above) and results on the Self-Assessment? Could the instrument be inaccurate in picking up your true philosophy of education? What does your philosophical orientation imply for how you will teach? Discuss. 

To be fair, I sort of cheated the initial questions about what I felt my educational philosophy was and said it was a hodgepodge of just about everything (some of that for certain philosophies was probably greatly overstated). But I feel like the Self-Assessment instrument did a pretty solid job. The description of Reconstrucionism in the power point was a little bit confusing and the description in the Scoring Guide for the Self-Assessment made it much clearer as to what it was. That second description makes me feel like that's a very accurate depiction of my view of education. I think the implication is that I'm going to teach in such a way where students are going to be driven to have conversations about the world around them. They're not just going to learn what can be found in the textbook. They're going to understand how what we're learning in class connects to real world. And they're going to understand that they have an obligation to make the world a better place than the way they originally found it. 

Philosophy of Education

 

ENGAGE: Teaching Philosophy

 

Why is it important to develop your own teaching philosophy?

 

The video "When I Become a Teacher..." presents a number of questionable teaching philosophies. But (and perhaps I'm being overly idealistic here) I don't think most people go into teaching holding these sorts of beliefs. One of the teachers featured in the video talks about being a year away from retirement, and I think it's that sense of teaching as being just a job, or something to be gotten through, which sets in after being in the profession a long time, that is the real enemy here. The idealism that exists when entering the profession becomes corroded as the realities of the profession set in. 

 

Having a teaching philosophy helps us combat the worst tendencies of the job and ensures that our sanity remains intact. It's important to have a teaching philosophy because it will help inform your instruction, and hopefully inform it in a positive way. Why you want to teach will come through in how you teach. When students can see that you have clear, meaningful reasons for teaching them, they're more likely to care about learning. To make what you teach much more than just a bunch of "stuff" students need to memorize and regurgitate, you need to provide perspective and context, and you can't do that if you haven't considered why they should care. And having a philosophy will help sustain you during the more difficult and frustrating stretches of the job.  

 

 ***

 

So here goes my attempt at briefly formulating my own teaching philosophy:

 

When I become a teacher, I want to teach my students about life. Sure, I want to teach them about history, but that's just a means to an end. History is a tool by which I will make students better informed people. While the video made a knock at the "sage on the stage" role of educators, I'm not opposed to the idea of teachers as purveyors of wisdom. After all, as we discussed during our September 29th virtual class session, teachers need to be thinking about how their instruction will translate into something useful for students in life outside of school and for those students who just aren't going to be, say, pursuing history beyond their classes in high school. As the Five Minute University demonstrated, most content knowledge is going to fall out of our students' heads, so we need to be teaching them more than just the content. Part of that is teaching useful skills, but part of that is also instilling useful real world knowledge. That means having conversations about and connecting history to current events and teaching students how to stay informed and be engaged citizens. The end goal as an educator, in my eyes, is to turn students into the kind of people you wouldn't mind running into on the street after they graduate; in other words, the goal is to mold them into good people and good citizens.