Bumper Sticker
I could see the bumper sticker ("SCHOOL: The place for…") going two very different ways; one is very positive and the other extremely negative. The bumper sticker could end with something like "The place for creating our future leaders", or "The place for molding our future citizens". But it could also go in a very different direction: "The place for indoctrinating the clueless masses" or the "The place for maintaining the status quo".
There are two distinct schools of thought among the masses about schools and education. The first is that although schools are flawed, they're important. There are hardworking teachers trying to provide quality education in spite of monumental challenges, and students will ultimately gain valuable social and intellectual skills. We know schools are kind of a mess, but that does not take away from how invaluable they are.
The second view is far more cynical. It questions why more basic life skills aren't part of the curriculum (i.e. financial skills like doing your taxes). It finds little value in what is being taught, and sometimes views it as a tool for social control. The role of schools from this perspective is to keep the masses complacent and incapable of questioning social, political and economic ills.
I fall somewhere in between these two camps. I'm no conspiracy theorist, but schools (especially my subject area, social studies) were created as tools of indoctrination and assimilation. The trend toward critical thinking and inquiry is a more recent phenomenon, and, even then, only a select number of teachers are actually attempting to instill this into students. While I'm idealistic about education and what it can achieve, I'm not blind to the day-to-day realities. It's tough for education to live up to the ideal we establish for it.
As you can tell, I don't sport bumper stickers on my car. There isn't room for ambiguity.
No comments:
Post a Comment