Friday, December 9, 2016

Final Thoughts

This post hopes to briefly sum up my thoughts on my Make a Difference Project, as well as the course as a whole.

Nature of Schools has primarily emphasized both the history and philosophies of education. The history has demonstrated the shortcomings but also the tremendous promise of American education. Many have been excluded from education. Education has not always lived up to its ideal as the "great equalizer". Education has always been defined by the era in which it takes place. The pendulum shifts back and forth on what the public thinks is correct and appropriate for education. All we can do is keep fighting the good fight, and hope that we land on the right side of history.

The wide range of educational philosophies points to how education is a truly human affair, defined by human foibles. No one has the exact answers as to what we need to do with education. Everyone has their perspective on the matter, and we all land differently on the philosophical spectrum. I find that my outlook takes a centrist approach, between extremes, between student-centric and teacher centric approaches. Crafting an educational philosophy is essential to ensuring effective instruction occurs in the classroom. Teachers need to know why they are in the profession, and be able to explain their philosophy to their students. Students are like sharks scenting blood; they know when blood is the water. They can sense phoniness and hollowness. Authenticity isn't something we see enough in teaching. Not enough educators have philosophical perspective underpinning their instruction, and therefore not enough teachers come across as genuine.

We need to be mindful of the history of education and our educational philosophy as we tackle instruction and curriculum. We should apply this framework from the course towards achieving the best possible practices. This is something we briefly considered in our Make a Difference Projects. We dwelled on problems facing education, and we wondered how we would like to make a legitimate, real-world impact in education. We took the theory and we attempted to put it into practice. My thoughts on testing and assessments weren't merely nice thought experiments; those are concrete things I intend to immediately use.

Schools may not always live up to their ideal, but we have to keep trying to reach that ideal. We have to be the change agent.

Thursday, December 8, 2016

Teaching with Technology

Elaborate

We were asked to create two lessons utilizing technology.

One of the lesson ideas I have is a long term lesson where students maintain digital journals through a Moodle-style site (like our e-class site), or through a blog site (like Blogger). The idea is to have students perform a lot of informal writing about open-ended history questions in hopes of developing students' writing skills. The more opportunities students have to write, the better they will be as writers and thinkers. These questions would act as scaffolding for students and prepare them for longer-form essay questions. This would build up their skills and their confidence. The journals would also help to form a community where students could respond to one another, and this would provide an chance for students to explore questions and concepts outside of the confines of the classroom. In other words, the classrom conversations expands beyond the class. The commenting and critiquing of peers' work also helps to form a safe environment in which students can help one another, and it will establish a shared knowledge base which will enhance everyone's understanding of course content. These questions could take on a variety of forms: Was Alexander the Great truly "great", and what does greatness, in fact, mean? Is the United States the new Roman Empire as many commentators have argued? Was Andrew Jackson a good or bad president, and should we overlook the many terrible things in favor of the many great things he did? The possibilities for types of writing are really endless.

The second lesson idea I have incorporates more effective applications of PowerPoint into direct instruction. I think PowerPoint is just fine for instruction, but that we've been using it poorly or incorrectly. You have to have things discuss. You can't just ask students to copy down information verbatim. Slides should pose questions, which help to frame the information and generate conversations. For instance, you could have a lesson on ancient Rome that shows the ruins of the Roman Empire and ask students to consider the story of how the civilization ended up that way. Hypothesizing is an essential and little used skill, particularly in social studies. Another question could be posed for a lesson on the French Revolution. You could show a young, strapping Napoleon Bonaparte next to a picture of Napoleon as a weak, old man utterly defeated. The students could be asked how we arrived from the first image to the second image. This is not only about hypothesizing but also about using causation and contextualization. You could also occasionally intersperse short video clips to emphasize key points. The success of the 13th, 14th and 15th amendments is much more impressive when you understand just how difficult it was to get those amendments passed. This is well demonstrated in the film Lincoln. 12 Years A Slave is the most accurate and heart-wrenching depiction of American slavery I've ever seen. Students will better understand the horrors of slavery when they recognize the extent of the brutality and dehumanization of the system. By playing to different skills and abilities, you're going to get through to the greatest number of students. These are only a handful of ways PowerPoint can be more effectively implemented.


Sunday, December 4, 2016

School of Your Dreams


My group didn't always agree on the specifics of our dream school, but there were certain fundamental things we all felt were true. That school hours should be reasonable. That teachers should be well versed in their subjects. That technology should be up to date and easily accessible. That students should have a say in what they learn, and that instruction should be used to encourage students' enthusiasm for learning. That the curriculum should move away from so much testing.

The ideal school doesn't exist, but, as I think you witnessed in all four of the group presentations, certain universal things are always strived for in schools. We need to keep pushing for that ideal.

Sunday, November 27, 2016

Classroom Layout


I'm a "keep it simple" kind of person. I don't think changing the classroom up all that much will seriously change up the results too much (particularly not at the higher adolescent levels I will be teaching at). Sure, the walls should have posters and students' assignments and inspiring quotes and things to help with scaffolding, and the overall design should inspire good karma and good feng shui. But no one has really discovered some magical new design for seating arrangements. Good, effective learning has a lot more to do with the teacher establishing the learning environment than it does with the arrangement of seats and rows.  

Friday, November 25, 2016

Your First Classroom

Explore and Explain

1. Peer reviewing could be a really effective way to improve instruction. The idea that everyone is working together to ensure students are learning and that instruction is successful seems smart. I could, however, see issues of implementing it and getting people on board. I've seen departments and faculty of schools fail to be collaborative or in agreement on plenty of issues to know that what's effective or right isn't necessarily what is accepted.

Peer reviewing might very well be more effective than traditional forms of review. The pop-ins by administrators aren't exactly the most substantial form of watchdog operation. They encourage people to slack off and to only be truly serious when they anticipate an observation (which they're always forewarned about in advance). Constant repeated observation and feedback from a variety of angles with the intent of improving instruction seems like a sensible practice. 

2. I imagine I'll be much more likely to use people I know as a resource over online resources. I may use online resources to prep or to prepare materials. But I'm much more likely to rely on the advice of individuals already in the profession who know what the job hiring and interviewing process is like.

The resources on finding teaching jobs (particularly those for New York, where I hope, if possible, to remain) appear to be the most useful. The resources for discovering available teaching positions to apply to may be helpful.

3. I'm actually familiar with teachers who have the National Board Certification. A lot of them are teachers deep into their teaching career who believe in the high quality of their instruction and wanted to challenge themselves. They also hoped to prove to themselves the strength of their instruction and role as an educator.

The idea is that a teacher should be so effective and strong that they could teach anywhere in the country, an option the certification grants upon acquisition.  I may pursue the national board certification, but probably not until fairly deep into my career when I'm well-established and comfortable.

The NBPTS: Latest Developments and Future Plans:

The NBPTS is trying to improve the level of certification of teachers. It is encouraging all teachers to become national board certified. It is pushing for better standards, ones that are more national in perspective and approach.   

Ultimately, it wants to do this in order to strengthen the profession, and produce more teachers who act as leaders in the profession. It wants to provide access to high quality materials and resources, and connections to board certified teachers who can share their expertise and experience.

4. Merit pay doesn't work. For one thing, it's highly difficult to implement, and even when implemented correctly it doesn't necessarily do what it sets out to do. It doesn't attract the best talent. The sort of people drawn to the profession are always going to be drawn to the profession no matter the type of pay, and merit pay won't deal with the weak, selfish people who drag down the good name of the profession.

I would not want to work in a merit pay environment. The system described in the New York Times article sounds like the best alternative system, but I have serious doubt of its effectiveness. It's hindered by its ability to measure teacher effectiveness; it's ultimately going to be tied to test scores. There's no good way of evaluating teachers that would make merit pay a viable option.

Tuesday, November 22, 2016

Qualities of a Good Teacher

ENGAGE: What do you Think?   

 

1. Sense of humor

 

C) 3

 

As the film Pulp Fiction so eloquently notes, "Personality goes a long way". I don't think humor is the defining feature of a good teacher. After all, teachers can compensate for a lack of liveliness or fun with other attributes such as a kindness or creativity. But teachers with a sense of humor tend to have an easier time getting along with their students and increasing motivation and interest in the classroom. 

 

2. Knowledge of subject matter  

 

E) 5 

 

Quite frankly I think this may be the most important quality in a teacher. Too many teachers are ill equipped to teach their subjects. Students aren't dumb; they can very quickly tell when a teacher doesn't know what they're talking about. Strong command of content increases student confidence in teacher which potentially (when matched up with an interesting personality) builds respect. Strong content knowledge also allows teachers to be more creative and flexible in their instruction. If you know what you're talking about, you have more possibilities as to what you can do and what directions you can take a class in. Social studies is a field with far too many people who have massive knowledge deficits and who therefore teach to the test and overly rely on textbooks. 

 

3. Manages behavior well

 

 E) 5

 

Scratch that; classroom management, contrary to my argument in the last question, is definitely the most important quality in a teacher. When classroom management is poor, no instruction and no learning can be achieved. Without some sense of order and without students behaving and listening, no classwork is going to get done. 

 

4. Enjoy and respect young people 

 

E) 5

 

I can't imagine why anyone would enter the profession if they didn't like young people. I know I certainly do. I find that stage in people's lives interesting and crucial. It's an important time in people's lives, and it's also a difficult one. And any way that teachers can ease that transition into adulthood and the real world is essential. I also think it's important that teachers help develop integrity, curiosity, and critical thinking skills, among others. Many students aren't going to develop these things if it doesn't happen here. That's a problem. Teachers who clearly don't like or don't care for young people are less likely to achieve these necessary developmental gains.

 

5. Adapt to change smoothly

 

D) 4

 

Teaching is, in part, about anticipating the unanticipated. The Mount's lessons are big in their emphasis on preparing lessons based on what you expect student responses to instruction are going to be. While you can always make certain safe guesses as to where the lesson is going to go, you can never fully predict the specific student responses and reaction. If a student asks a great question or raises a worthwhile concern, you can't ignore these things and they may even make instruction better than you could have ever imagined it being. Adapting on the fly is a key skill.

 

6. Motivating and inspiring 

 

E) 5

 

In truth, this quality should really be rated like a "3"; similar to a sense of humor, it's not truly essential, but it definitely doesn't hurt. While it isn't technically essential, I think teachers that go above and beyond and are typically considered great possess this quality. Great teachers don't just teach their content; they teach life lessons, they instill a sense of purpose and responsibility, and they encourage students to take action in their own life and out in the world. 

 

7. Creative and innovative

 

D) 4

 

I'm a no frills sort of person. I think flashy and exciting instruction does a lot to come across as spectacular without necessarily being superior to traditional forms of instruction. That said, I don't think it hurts to try new things out in the classroom. Teachers should never be complacent, and they should always consider how they can tackle content from new directions and angles. 

 

8. Cool in a crisis 

 

D) 4

 

Like adapting to change smoothly, being cool in a crisis is valuable for a teacher. Teaching can be a stressful profession. It's demanding and challenging, and we ask a lot of our teachers: to be not only educators, but also role models and mentors, and to attend to students' personal, emotional and social needs as well as their educational, cognitive and intellectual ones. Panicked teachers who cannot remain calm are going to be incapable of controlling their classrooms.

 

9. Good with adults and workmates

 

C) 3 

 

While it doesn't hurt to be friendly and respectful of colleagues and collaborative with them when possible, I don't think it's the most important aspect of instruction. Teachers spend far more time with students and therefore need much better relationships with young people than adults. However, an ability to have strong relationships with adults is a good indication of how you maintain relationships with everyone.

 

10. Approaches things with variety

 

C) 3

 

I think we sometimes have magical or wishful thinking about instruction. We know certain things work, and certain things don't work. We also know that certain things (i.e. power point, direct instruction, group projects) have terrible reputations, but more often due to the implementation of instruction rather than due to the type of instruction itself. It's good to vary instruction when possible and try to make it not just be solely direct instruction. But the assumption that variety always entails quality is incredibly reductive. I've seen teachers that have varied instruction but it didn't matter because the application of that variety was lukewarm. 

 

11. Well-organized

 

C) 3 

 

As someone who is highly disorganized, I have to disagree. I don't think it hurts to have some degree of organization and planning. But messy minds are sometimes very good at what they do, thank you very much.

 

12. Reflective and introspective

 

C) 4

 

Good teachers are constantly dwelling upon how their instruction went and how they can best improve it. They're metacognitive, and they encourage their students to be the same. They debrief everything and they are always striving to determine how to be the best they can possibly be.   

Friday, November 4, 2016

Future Me

Elaborate:

Here is the letter I sent to my future self:
 
Dear Future Patrick,

I am writing you this letter for my ED 5210: Nature of Schools grad class.  It is the Fall of 2016, and you are just short of a year away from student teaching in the Fall of 2017.  I realize that you are nervous and anxious.  This is a problematic feature of your personality.  And although it drives your success and ambition, it also makes you occasionally doubt and second guess yourself.  You’re going to have to learn to move away from that as you move forward in teaching.  You’re also going to have to temper your kindness just a little bit.  You can only kill students with kindness so much; at the end of the day, you have to be able to put your foot down. 

That said, there’s a lot to be said in your favor as a future teacher.  You’re knowledgeable, you’re passionate, and you have a genuine empathy and affection for young people.  You went into your subject area with idealistic, reform-minded goals, and, although they’re probably not entirely achievable, your educational philosophy is an admirable one.  You’re in the right mindset for the profession.

The Mount’s program has provided a lot of useful philosophical and pedagogical resources to underpin and shape these views and this direction.  The most important elements of the program have been those that have had you reflect on why you want to be a teacher, what type of teacher you want to be, and how these things will impact your instruction.  Remember, you’ve actually been able to use this in real life situations when you’ve argued students in circles about why education and history matter.  You have a full arsenal to sustain you and to (hopefully) convert the skeptical adolescent. 

Fair warning Future Me, here is where the letter briefly shifts into rant mode.  You went into this profession because of your own experiences with teachers.  You had some great teachers, and you had teachers that made you reconsider the subject of history, a subject that most people tend to dismiss as pointless, boring and useless.  Social studies education is in crisis.  People can talk all they want about the illiteracy of students in the STEMs (I don’t deny it); however, social studies education frequently seems like it is under siege.  Teaching to the test, underqualified and undermotivated instructors, teaching history as an endless series of terms, and an awful cultural mentality about the purpose of history all contribute to people not taking the subject seriously.  Students can see the importance of science even when they struggle with it, but they rarely struggle with history.  Instead, they struggle to find reasons to care about it.  The why of it all is consistently missing.  We just don’t connect it enough in any meaningful way to the world around students or their own lives.  Since social studies is the subject most directly connected to the real world and students’ lives, that seems like a crying shame.    

So this is a reminder as to why you’re going to be great out there in the field.  Not only do you know your stuff, and in a committed enough way to combat some of the previously mentioned tendencies, but you also, well, care.  You care about young people.  You want to see them grow as individuals and citizens.  You want them to think, deeply and seriously.  You want to see them become passionate.  You are also, admittedly, secretly a kid at heart, and you appreciate the sense of wonder young people still retain. 

Oh the places you’ll go, Future Me.  I look forward to them.

Good luck,
Past Patrick

Diverse Learners

Explore and Explain:

       1. What diverse learners are there in today's classrooms?
       2. What does a brain research provide teachers with to adjust their teaching in the digital
       age?
       3. What is a UDL? How its principles help teachers improve planning and teaching?

1. There are wide variety of learners in today’s classrooms, and they’re all facing different issues.  Some might have attention problems such as ADHD.  Some may have language issues such as English as a New Language or dyslexia.  They may have some form of physical disability.  They might struggle with emotional problems.  As the educator in the video puts it, one size fits all education just won’t satisfy the needs of all these diverse learners.

2. Brain research reminds us of the diverse learner issue discussed in the first video and question. Different students have different cognitive struggles when it comes to learning.  Each brain processes information differently.  Some struggle with gathering information.  Others have difficulty organizing that information.  Others have problems with why they should care or be motivated about learning. 

3. UDL stands for Universal Design for Learning.  Universal Design is a feature that helps to include all people regardless of ability or background, such as closed captioning or speaker phones. 

UDL’s principles help improve planning and teaching by encouraging and allowing teachers to customize instruction to best suit the needs of their students.  UDL has a lot in common with differentiated instruction.  Instruction is tailored to the learning needs of students, which ensures the most successful and effective instruction and curriculum for everyone. 

Simile

 Engage


The simile that I arrived at is a little hokey, but I like how it fits with what we've discussed about education and technology, and my own views on the topic:

Educational Technology for me is like... a river guiding a boat.

What I mean by this is that technology is a means for facilitating student learning.  We have to be weary that technology doesn’t dominate and ultimately become the sole purpose for instruction.  However, technology when utilized correctly can make instruction more creative and engaging, and can play to students’ strengths, abilities and interests. This is how we hope a river will behave when we travel on it: smooth, gentle, and in tandem with our ship. What we don't want are choppy waters, dangerous rapids, or any other impediments to safe and easy travel. And that's what we also hope for in both education and integration of education in the classroom. 

Sunday, October 23, 2016

Stranger Things

ELABORATE: What Do you Think?

What school and community resources might you use to help immigrant students?

I would encourage immigrant students to seek English as a New Language services if that is necessary for them and they are a first generation immigrant.  I would also suggest that they get involved with community outreach programs the school may have.  This will help to get people to stop viewing immigrant students as Others who should be feared. To bridge the cultural barrier and to build acceptance, immigrant students might form clubs (like the "Russian Club" shown in the video) so that people may begin to understand their culture and so that a dialogue will be initiated.

Multiculturalism

EVALUATE

I was quite proud of my ability to successfully pass the Multicultural Literacy Game-Quiz. Admittedly, I did not know all of these. I knew the majority from my knowledge about history and culture. But about 3 (Nisei, Lumpia, Step Show) towards the end I arrived at through process of elimination. 

 

This really is a diverse nation, and we need to be better about acknowledging that diversity. If our instruction is not culturally relevant, we won't get through to our students and they won't learn. So in a sense, it is a tiny bit of a wake up call that I still have certain multicultural blind-spots. I need to work at that.  

Different Ways of Learning

ENGAGE: Different Ways of Learning

1. Schools and classrooms should be quiet places to promote thinking and learning.

B. Agree

There are times when it's perfectly fine for classrooms to be a little more chaotic, filled with energy and the noise of conversation and debate. But these times have to be specific parts of the lessons and curriculum. They cannot be the typical expected baseline state of the school. It is difficult to run a classroom and to maintain student attention when they're not able to focus.   

2. All classrooms and libraries should be well lighted to reduce eyestrain.

A. Strongly Agree

Schools should be well lit so that students are able to get their work done, but also so that they feel safe and secure in their classrooms. Brighter lighting not only reduces eyestrain, but it increases a sense of a positivity.

3. Difficult subjects, such as math, should be offered in the morning, when students are fresh and alert.

C. Disagree

This just feels like a bad question. Students are rarely fresh and alert in the morning. Teachers prefer early classes because students are quiet and subdued as a result of only recently having gotten out of bed.  But I'm not sure if that necessarily means students are more prepared to think during this time of the day. In fact, the opposite may very well be true. The argument against classes later in the day is that students are less focused due to having more energy (especially after lunch) and being all ready to head back home at the end of the school day.

4. School thermostats should be set at 68 to 72 degrees Fahrenheit to establish a comfortable learning environment.

B. Agree

I'm perfectly fine with that temperature; it seems reasonable. But everyone's body reacts differently to the temperature buildings are set to. So it very well could bother some people.

5. Eating and drinking in classrooms should be prohibited.

C. Disagree

Perhaps if you were a science teacher who was concerned about lab materials mixing with the food and drinks students were having, you might be concerned about eating in the classroom. But as a social studies teacher, food and drinks aren't that large of a concern. I'm as worried as anyone else of students making a mess as a result of eating. But some students don't have lunches or need to eat something to keep up their energy. If it helps them maintain focus and contribute to class, I'm not going to oppose it.

6. Classroom periods should run between forty-five and fifty-five minutes to ensure adequate time to investigate significant issues and practice important skills.

B. Agree

I wouldn't want a period shorter than somewhere in the 40 minute ranger; there just wouldn't be enough time to actually do anything. That said, I also wouldn't want a class period running more than 45 minutes quite honestly. Students quickly get jittery towards the end of a class period, and the longer the period drags out, the less likely they will be paying attention. Plenty can get done in 45 minutes, and if you really want to spend a lot of time on something, you can break it up over the course of more than one day.

7. Students must be provided with adequate work areas, including chairs and desks, where they can sit quietly for the major part of their learning and study.

B. Agree

Students need adequate work spaces. But sitting perfectly quiet as they learn isn't necessarily the most effective form of instruction. They'll be times where students need to study and learn quietly at their desk, but I wouldn't expect that to be the case all the time.

8. Emphasis should be placed on reading textbooks and listening to lectures, for this is how students learn best.

C. Disagree

Textbooks are boring. Social studies textbooks are perhaps the most boring academic textbooks of all. They fail to frame history as a narrative, they avoid trying to stir up controversy, they leave out some of the most interesting and fascinating details, they fail to make connections among topics, they fail to provide context, and they don't make connections to current or modern events.  Social studies textbooks are also frequently inaccurate (As demonstrated so beautifully in James W. Loewen's Lies My Teacher Told Me), favoring moral instillment over accurate history.

Lecturing is boring if overused. But, as I've repeatedly said, direct instruction is inevitably the primary form of instruction; so we need find ways to improve it and make it engaging, rather than writing it off as terrible. Textbook readings can be replaced with higher quality alternative readings. The same can be achieved for direct instruction.

Sunday, October 16, 2016

Digital Pedagogy

EXPLORE: What is Digital Pedagogy?

 

Digital pedagogy is simply enhancing traditional pedagogy with digital technology. The article mentions the recent trend of the "flipped classroom", where instruction happens at home through online resources and then students practice skills based on that instruction in the classroom. This seems like it will be particularly effective for math and science classrooms, which might find themselves struggling to create time for reinforcement of problem solving. 

 

The article mocks power points, but I think it's a little too harsh on the second most popular feature of the Microsoft Office Suite. Notes still need to be delivered to students, and the alternative is the old talk and chalk method. The problem isn't the delivery system but rather the delivery. Power Point tends to be boring because teachers who use it tend to be... well, boring. Power Point can be tremendously useful when teacher elaborate on terms and concepts presented on the power point slides and when they have additional information to discuss beyond the power point. Too often teachers simply repeat what's up on the power point. Your students can read it; now give them a reason to care.

I'm a fan of the idea of students essentially journaling using Moodle sites (such as our own e-class) or blogging sites. Social studies requires students to express their opinions about historical events with competing opinions and perspectives, and contested facts and details. Students, in my opinion, should also engage with current events and formulate opinions about pressing topics about things going on in the world. They should also learn to make connections between the history they're learning and events happening in the news. Informal writing could be done with your standard pencil and looseness, but students may find more enjoyment and ease in a familiar technological resource.


Digital pedagogy, in short, is just pedagogy. Pedagogy for a new era, but pedagogy who's fundamentals don't look all that different from the past.

Teachers as Facilitators

EXPLORE and EXPLAIN: PPT Models of Teaching

 

Teachers as facilitators is a trend we're increasingly seeing in education. Instead of teachers simply directly providing all the necessary information and being the key source of knowledge, teachers as facilitators act as guides and generate circumstances and tasks under which students will learn. When the teacher is a facilitator, students discover knowledge on their own and learn more independently and collaboratively. Instruction tries to move away from traditional direct instruction. 

Falling into Place

EXPLORE: Four Models of Instruction

 

I find myself falling between Social Constructvism and Cognitive Constructivism. The former emphasizes the environment in which students learn, while the latter focuses on the individual existing educational foundations of students. I think education is based on a combination of both. It's based on what students bring to the table, but it's also about promoting a learning environment in which students learn. Learning is built into the social and cultural circumstances on instruction. But I think Social Constructvism makes the great point that motivation is based on a combination extrinsic things (grades, teacher expectations) and intrinsic things (interest in a topic). 

Teaching to the Test

ENGAGE: What do you think?

 

If the primary goal of education is to create genuine interest in students of learning, then we're doing a pretty terrible job at it. We bribe, we coerce, we shame. But we rarely find ways to create authentic interest. It's temporary and based around getting a good good grade, or out competing some fellow student, or making sure we pass the test. These are bad ways to create motivation in students. 

 

School reform advocate Alfie Kohn gets at all of this and more. He makes the case that running schools like a business is a problematic system. Standards and grades are all about ensuring accountability, like a company to its shareholders. It becomes less about a real concern about actual learning and more about visibly proving "success" through data points. Aren't happy with teacher performance? Tie it to student test grades. 

 

Education has become obsessed with rote memorization at the expense of critical thinking. We prize worksheets and poorly made power point presentations, endless homework (a series of busybody worksheets that insult students' intelligence) and prescribed tests (that we, of course, teach to). Kohn argues that if schools emphasized a Progressive education more then they would see students capable of making meaningful decisions.  

 

Schools underwhelm gifted learners. They're bored, they fail to be challenged, and they're frustrated with the repetition. Schools stress out struggling learners. They're frustrated, and they typically coast by under the radar,   

 

Students need to be legitimately challenged because it encourages them to think in ways that will make them prepared for the world. They'll be able to challenge and critique authority, and they'll call into question everything. They'll be inquisitive, and they won't accept things at face value. Ultimately, we need to make students who can affect real world change and know how to go about achieving it. The current system just doesn't do that.  

The Future of Education



Looking to the future of education is a reminder that some things will change drastically and others will largely remain the same. 

After reading the article 5 Big Ways Education Will Change By 2020, I was reminded of the extraordinary impact technology has had on society.  But as the article points out, I was also reminded that despite the incredible change technology as wrought, classrooms look very similar to how they’ve always looked.  People still remain skeptical of online class (even one such as the one we’re doing right now), and people still doubt technology really being able to entirely replace certain fundamental aspects of education.  But I think the article is right, more students are going to being attending classes remotely; this will happen as result of digital technology and students having been raised on digital tech, but also because of the cost benefits that distance education offers.

However, we shouldn’t get ahead of ourselves about the role of technology.  Technology may be new and shiny and seem like the cure-all-fix-all solution, but it can’t replace the role of a quality teacher.  Teachers should be determining instruction not technology.  The tail shouldn’t wag the dog.

Higher education is important, but it isn’t for everyone.  Too many students are encouraged to go to college to get degrees they may not have even gotten the first place if they had considered alternative options.  As important as I think history is, a history degree won’t build a house or fix a car.  Trade schools should be taken more seriously than they have been.

As I’ve said repeatedly, student focused education has its place and is not seen often enough in the classroom.  But I also find that it has its limits.  Just like teachers aren’t going away, neither is direct instruction.  Students should have a voice, students’ interests should be taken seriously, and greater space for meeting their needs should be created.  Greater co-operative and inquiry-based instruction should be initiated, and more extracurricular activities should be offered.  But I think, ultimately, the greater problem is disinterested and under-qualified educators.  

I think the final point the article makes is probably its most astute.  The goal of education is ultimately to prepare students for the world.  A changing world requires a changing approach to education.  That will mean that various aspects of all the previous discussed changes will begin to see greater application in the world of education.