Strengths and Weaknesses of the American School System
The "New Professional" article by Parker J. Palmer makes the great point that just because you have a school, doesn't mean you have an education. No matter how noble the initial goals of an institution are, ultimately the goal of institutions becomes to perpetuate themselves. In other words, institutions eventually have one goal: to make sure they keep existing. They stop trying to do their job efficiently or well, but rather to make it look like they're doing their job just competently enough so that nobody can call them into question. (This whole issue reminds me of the tv series The Wire, which everyone should watch if they haven't already).
The article also makes the argument that it's ultimately on us to become undercover agents to dismantle to the institutions from within. People tend to feel powerless in the face of institutions. They are above and beyond us, entirely outside our control. Yet we exist within them and, therefore, are part of them. Institutions try make us feel voiceless, and so we tend not to speak up or criticize them even when we feel like they're problems
We also make students voiceless as a result. The article offers up the great point that our lack of desire to question institutions is culturally based. Our educational system places a higher value on the memorization of concrete information than on critical thinking skills. Whenever students wish to speak their mind, we tend to shut them down if they're not doing it within institutionally sanctioned times. If it isn't part of the curriculum, we simply don't allot time for it. That's a real concern.
The American School System's biggest problem is that it tends to be run like a business. Test scores and graduation rates are the numbers you can show off to the public to demonstrate that they're getting a high return on their investment. But education, like the article notes, is about a lot of very subjective things that can't be articulated in a nice, neat way.
I think the public perception of this problem mostly stacks up with this image. The public largely understands that there's an educational crisis and that it exists due to institutional practices that are fundamentally out of date, corrupt or backwards.
This post probably features a little too much gloom and doom. The upside to the American School System is that, like the article argues, teachers are capable of being change agents. Once inside the system, you don't have to be beholden to it. Once inside it, you can do your job well in spite of external factors. Ultimately, you can make a real difference in the lives of students, and therefore within the institution and society.
3 Discussion Questions for Week 1:
1. Has the negative public perception of American public schools been overstated? How and why?
2. Why does such a strong effort exist to discredit teaching as a profession?
3. To what extent is Rita Pierson right that education is actually about the development of relationships?
No comments:
Post a Comment