View Videos (Week 2):
I'm just going offer a few brief thoughts on the videos we were asked to watch.
This video probably gets a little to conspiratorial for its own good (pretty much implying that America is setting itself up to become a neo-Nazi style fascist state (or something to that effect)). But up until those final moments where it completely loses touch with reality, the video is actually making a pretty good point about the nature of the public school system.
The model that America adopted its educational system from, the Prussian model, is obsessed with instilling obedience to authority. It isn't concerned with creating independent thinkers. You can still see the residual effects of this to this day. The structure, the curriculum, and the ways instruction are doled out are fixated on order, discipline and authoritarian control. They're also intent on indoctrination, creating blind loyalty to the state.
This video gets at a similar idea to the previous video: American education was established to preserve the status quo. Education was designed to preserve social class, gender, and racial differences and inequalities. Thomas Jefferson only wanted to aristocratic children to get a very advanced education, and didn't believe women should be included.
And as Noah Webster saw it, it was also a means of indoctrination. He saw history as means of establishing and instilling national ideals. Webster wasn't opposed to falsifying or distorting history to achieve this goal. He help mythologize the Founding Fathers (through stories like Washington and the cherry tree). This has been a problem ever since with American history; culture wars continue to be fought with some feeling that our history in schools should only be about American achievements and accomplishments, and others arguing that the skeleton's in America's closet need to be exposed.
Class sizes are too big? Schools are underfunded? Not enough national or professional standards for education and teaching exist? Teachers need more professional development?
That could all describe many of the complaints lobbed against the public school system today. And yet it also acts as an apt description of the criticisms Horace Mann made when he explored and reformed the American education in the 1830's. As they say: The more things change, the more they stay the same.
It's easy to forget that the United States came into existence in the Age of Imperialism. This was a time where Europeans were trying to find scientific proof that they were superior to the foreign peoples they were conquering and colonizing. You hear that language in the justifications for why blacks shouldn't be allowed the same education as whites. White Americans made the argument that blacks were biologically different and inferior and therefore did not require the same quality of education.
"Would you rather work in a factory or a school?" Of course the kid picked the factory, just about every child attending school would choose to avoid going if given the opportunity.
To be fair, the schools were much, much worse in the early 20th century. The response (Progressive Education), however, is one that still resonates to this day. The greater emphasis on creativity and autonomy and less on direct instruction are battles we're still facing as we attempt to reform schools to this day.
I sort of appreciate the "career tracking" process. I get that as a systematic process it's discriminatory and it's done at the expense of educational experiences elsewhere in the curriculum. However, I think that school isn't necessarily for everyone, and that not everyone will go to college. So, as a result, we need to encourage certain students to enter a trade or go to a technical school. The fixation on the value of college above all else discourages some students who just don't see the value in education.
At the same time, I disagree with the old adage "Does a bricklayer really need to know Shakespeare?". I feel that there's something to be gained from all subjects. There are skills, thought processes, and basic informational things that are invaluable in math, science, English and history.
1) Americanization is a pretty frightening process. White Anglo-Saxon Protestant values are considered the only important cultural values, and all other competing values are exterminated. Schools are ground zero for this kind of activity. This election cycle has been a reminder of how problematic it can be when we obsessively assume certain cultural values are more American than others.
2) I agree to an extent with Theodore Bestor here. Schools consistently fail to provide intellectually rigorous academic activities. Progressive Education may provide choices, but it doesn't always get people to think. I appreciate Progressive attempts at allowing for creative exploration of student interests, but there is part of me that feels that it does sound a little wishy-washy.
No comments:
Post a Comment