Wednesday, September 28, 2016
Mixed Feelings
EVALUATE: What Do You Think?
1. Competition is key to improving school performance.
C. Disagree
This question makes schools seem like a business. Throwing schools out into the free market isn't going to guarantee the improvement of school performance. It will simply make the school system act like a capitalist system: some schools will improve greatly and some will tank. This will especially be true if no regulation and oversight is in place. Improvement of schools needs to occur across the board and not just at the highest level. And we need to stop treating schools like they should be in competition with one another; they should all be performing at a high level regardless of their location.
2. Schools continue to be academically weak, and stronger academic standards are needed.
B. Somewhat Agree
I have mixed feelings about common core. I think it has good intentions but I also feel that it's stifling in its approach. It ultimately ends up doing exactly what it sets out to avoid doing. I feel that academic weakness is a real issue for schools, but it has more to do with teaching to the test, rote memorization and under-qualified and under motivated faculty.
3. Schools do a great job in preparing students for vocational careers.
C. Disagree
Schools do a terrible job at preparing students for vocational careers. I strongly believe in the importance and necessity of history, but I'm not fooling myself that it will make you prepared for a technical trade. Most education is designed to mold the character and critical thinking of students, not to give them skills applicable for a trade.
4. Schools and teachers are very involved with the personal values and beliefs of students.
A. Agree
They are, and they should be. My personal belief is that education is supposed to be about turning students into good people and good citizens. We should be providing values and beliefs that will set them on the right path for the future.
5. Schools emphasize test scores at the expense of other kinds of evaluation.
A. Agree
Schools most definitely emphasize test scores to an unhealthy degree. America loves number (This is despite that fact that we're practically numerically illiterate). You throw a statistic at Americans and they'll think it explains everything. Tangible numbers make us feel like we have a better grasp of the success and failure of schools. But all the truly important stuff about education is impossible to measure. Tests are just bad measures of educational success; they discourage enthusiasm for learning and they takeaway valuable time from instruction.
6. Schools do an admirable job of moving children out of poverty into middle class life.
C. Disagree
Schools are supposed to be the great equalizer, providing equal opportunities for all. But as Jonathan Kozol so vividly depicted, schools in high poverty areas face tremendous obstacles. Very few people coming through them ever get out.
7. Home schooling is an effective alternative to the typical public school.
C. Disagree
There's a Progressive educational spin to be put on homeschooling. Students get to explore their interest in a more creative manner. But while that may be true, students are missing out on valuable socialization and the resources that come with an actual school facility.
8. Students care about the less fortunate, both here and overseas.
B. Somewhat Agree
Students care about the less fortunate, but it is mostly in an abstract sense. Most students don't do charity work or find ways to raise money or help the less fortunate. And when they do, it tends to be because their parents or teachers coerced them into doing it, or because it will look good on a college transcript. Truly altruistic individuals are few and far between.
9. Competition is key to improving student performance.
B. Somewhat Agree
Unlike competition on the macro level which I frowned upon, competition can be healthy on a micro level. Competition can be a game which can lead to excitement, enthusiasm and commitment. Competing with one's peers, can make some people more interested in doing well. But the competition is ultimately still tied to grades and as long as grades are the most important aspect of education, we're never truly going to see student performance improve.
10. Schools are stronger academically today then they have ever been before.
D. I Don't Know
I can talk boldly and with conviction all I want about all those previous questions, but the simple fact of the matter is that I'm not sure how things are right now with education, or how things stand compared to the past. I can't tell how much of my feelings towards the problems with education are due to the cultural mentality that exists as a result of A Nation at Risk, and how much of it is due to genuine flaws. I know there are definitely problems, but I couldn't say if these are problems that were already in place (perhaps for decades even before now) or more recently occurring. I also couldn't say how much of it is due to failed policy decisions like No Child Left Behind and how much of it is due to the issues NCLB was attempting (terribly) to fix. My instinct is to say "no, we're not academically stronger", but part of me thinks that this is inaccurate and that things have been this way for a long time.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment