Saturday, October 8, 2016
Where Do You Stand?
ELABORATE: Where do you Stand?
Here is my Emaze presentation about where I stand on the philosophy spectrum.
Do you find yourself influenced more by the arguments supporting teacher-centered approaches, or those advocating student-centered approaches? Are there elements of each that you find appealing? How will your classroom practices reflect your philosophy?
The self-assessment test "Who Are you as an Educator" pegged me as a Social Reconstructionist, but the placement of it on the spectrum for "Where Do You Stand on the Philosophy Spectrum?" makes it seem far too much to the student-centered approach to education. If we go by the spectrum, I'm probably a Progressive. However, I've repeatedly made criticisms of Progressivism in posts on this blog. My biggest critique is that, as I understand it, its approach to education is vague and difficult to pin down. I understand being concerned about students' interests and being creative, but I feel that Progressivism is impractical and doesn't fully grasp the realities of day-to-day education. Progressivism, to me, ignores the important role of an instructor. While teachers can be great big bores who don't build instruction to engage students more thoroughly, that doesn't mean that they don't matter what-so-ever. Direct instruction has gotten a bad name; however, it's invariably the chief form of instruction, and educational philosophies that don't acknowledge this and attempt to find ways to improve it are doing a disservice to teachers.
Ultimately, however, I keep falling towards student centered approaches whenever I assess myself for it. But as I mentioned in in a previous post, I find something worth borrowing in just about every educational philosophy. There isn't a one size fit all philosophy that could possibly suit all my philosophical beliefs or needs.
I imagine my classroom practices will feature a variety of approaches to instruction, depending on what I'm teaching, who I'm teaching and how I can make it work for what I believe education should look like.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment