ENGAGE: Different Ways of Learning
1. Schools and classrooms should be quiet places to promote thinking and learning.
B. Agree
There are times when it's perfectly fine for classrooms to be a little more chaotic, filled with energy and the noise of conversation and debate. But these times have to be specific parts of the lessons and curriculum. They cannot be the typical expected baseline state of the school. It is difficult to run a classroom and to maintain student attention when they're not able to focus.
2. All classrooms and libraries should be well lighted to reduce eyestrain.
A. Strongly Agree
Schools should be well lit so that students are able to get their work done, but also so that they feel safe and secure in their classrooms. Brighter lighting not only reduces eyestrain, but it increases a sense of a positivity.
3. Difficult subjects, such as math, should be offered in the morning, when students are fresh and alert.
C. Disagree
This just feels like a bad question. Students are rarely fresh and alert in the morning. Teachers prefer early classes because students are quiet and subdued as a result of only recently having gotten out of bed. But I'm not sure if that necessarily means students are more prepared to think during this time of the day. In fact, the opposite may very well be true. The argument against classes later in the day is that students are less focused due to having more energy (especially after lunch) and being all ready to head back home at the end of the school day.
4. School thermostats should be set at 68 to 72 degrees Fahrenheit to establish a comfortable learning environment.
B. Agree
I'm perfectly fine with that temperature; it seems reasonable. But everyone's body reacts differently to the temperature buildings are set to. So it very well could bother some people.
5. Eating and drinking in classrooms should be prohibited.
C. Disagree
Perhaps if you were a science teacher who was concerned about lab materials mixing with the food and drinks students were having, you might be concerned about eating in the classroom. But as a social studies teacher, food and drinks aren't that large of a concern. I'm as worried as anyone else of students making a mess as a result of eating. But some students don't have lunches or need to eat something to keep up their energy. If it helps them maintain focus and contribute to class, I'm not going to oppose it.
6. Classroom periods should run between forty-five and fifty-five minutes
to ensure adequate time to investigate significant issues and practice
important skills.
B. Agree
I wouldn't want a period shorter than somewhere in the 40 minute ranger; there just wouldn't be enough time to actually do anything. That said, I also wouldn't want a class period running more than 45 minutes quite honestly. Students quickly get jittery towards the end of a class period, and the longer the period drags out, the less likely they will be paying attention. Plenty can get done in 45 minutes, and if you really want to spend a lot of time on something, you can break it up over the course of more than one day.
7. Students must be provided with adequate work areas, including chairs and
desks, where they can sit quietly for the major part of their learning
and study.
B. Agree
Students need adequate work spaces. But sitting perfectly quiet as they learn isn't necessarily the most effective form of instruction. They'll be times where students need to study and learn quietly at their desk, but I wouldn't expect that to be the case all the time.
8. Emphasis should be placed on reading textbooks and listening to lectures, for this is how students learn best.
C. Disagree
Textbooks are boring. Social studies textbooks are perhaps the most boring academic textbooks of all. They fail to frame history as a narrative, they avoid trying to stir up controversy, they leave out some of the most interesting and fascinating details, they fail to make connections among topics, they fail to provide context, and they don't make connections to current or modern events. Social studies textbooks are also frequently inaccurate (As demonstrated so beautifully in James W. Loewen's Lies My Teacher Told Me), favoring moral instillment over accurate history.
Lecturing is boring if overused. But, as I've repeatedly said, direct instruction is inevitably the primary form of instruction; so we need find ways to improve it and make it engaging, rather than writing it off as terrible. Textbook readings can be replaced with higher quality alternative readings. The same can be achieved for direct instruction.
No comments:
Post a Comment