Explore and Explain
1. Peer reviewing could be a really effective way to improve instruction. The idea that everyone is working together to ensure students are learning and that instruction is successful seems smart. I could, however, see issues of implementing it and getting people on board. I've seen departments and faculty of schools fail to be collaborative or in agreement on plenty of issues to know that what's effective or right isn't necessarily what is accepted.
Peer reviewing might very well be more effective than traditional forms of review. The pop-ins by administrators aren't exactly the most substantial form of watchdog operation. They encourage people to slack off and to only be truly serious when they anticipate an observation (which they're always forewarned about in advance). Constant repeated observation and feedback from a variety of angles with the intent of improving instruction seems like a sensible practice.
2. I imagine I'll be much more likely to use people I know as a resource over online resources. I may use online resources to prep or to prepare materials. But I'm much more likely to rely on the advice of individuals already in the profession who know what the job hiring and interviewing process is like.
The resources on finding teaching jobs (particularly those for New York, where I hope, if possible, to remain) appear to be the most useful. The resources for discovering available teaching positions to apply to may be helpful.
3. I'm actually familiar with teachers who have the National Board Certification. A lot of them are teachers deep into their teaching career who believe in the high quality of their instruction and wanted to challenge themselves. They also hoped to prove to themselves the strength of their instruction and role as an educator.
The idea is that a teacher should be so effective and strong that they could teach anywhere in the country, an option the certification grants upon acquisition. I may pursue the national board certification, but probably not until fairly deep into my career when I'm well-established and comfortable.
The NBPTS: Latest Developments and Future Plans:
The NBPTS is trying to improve the level of certification of teachers. It is encouraging all teachers to become national board certified. It is pushing for better standards, ones that are more national in perspective and approach.
Ultimately, it wants to do this in order to strengthen the profession, and produce more teachers who act as leaders in the profession. It wants to provide access to high quality materials and resources, and connections to board certified teachers who can share their expertise and experience.
4. Merit pay doesn't work. For one thing, it's highly difficult to implement, and even when implemented correctly it doesn't necessarily do what it sets out to do. It doesn't attract the best talent. The sort of people drawn to the profession are always going to be drawn to the profession no matter the type of pay, and merit pay won't deal with the weak, selfish people who drag down the good name of the profession.
I would not want to work in a merit pay environment. The system described in the New York Times article sounds like the best alternative system, but I have serious doubt of its effectiveness. It's hindered by its ability to measure teacher effectiveness; it's ultimately going to be tied to test scores. There's no good way of evaluating teachers that would make merit pay a viable option.

I think that I have to agree with your stance on merit pay. Even if it was set up in a way in which it could work, it seems to bring more negative aspects to the work environment of a teacher than positive ones. The possibility of it creating rifts between colleagues is an especially troubling thought for me...
ReplyDeleteOh, I hadn't even thought about rifts between colleagues. That would be terrible.
DeleteI don't think people understand that trying to treat schools as a competitive market place, a free market capitalist system, doesn't work because it ultimately runs into human shortcomings.
I've seen the peer review work in the Newburgh School system. I've been told about it. I've never actually seen it with my own eyes. But I do agree with the administration reviews here. I think we are on our "best behavior" when we are viewed by administrators. I think we get better feedback from a peer than an administrator. I don't know how I feel about Merit Pay. According to what I've read, it can be good and bad. I guess it depends on the situation
ReplyDelete